While back I was talking with my friends about the iPhone Revolution, and I was kinda disagree with them that this is anything bit revolutionary device in terms of UI, it is a device that actually “evolve” the UI and then it packages itself in such a way that from surface it does look like the “Revolutionary Device” and it lead the Android UI which heavily borrowed the application item representation from PC/Mac.
Obviously we all know that Android is actually took some “hints” from iPhone, and you know where else these Android & iPhone got inspiration, yup, one and only Windows Phone 6.0/6.5. This last sentence will make some outburst, however here is what I experienced since April 2003 till today’s mobile phone usage.
Sidekick Black & White: Scrolling Menu (different approach)

Nokia 3660: Menu Screen and Icon Placement. (video)
Nokia 3660

Nokia N91: For Music Player, but same Application Menu Page

Nokia E65: Icon on Taskbar.

T-Mobile Dash: Menu Page/Start Page

iPhone 1, iPhone 3G & iPhone 3GS: The whole package was surreal that’s why I bought it.

HTC HD7 Windows Phone 7: Content oriented approach, Outlook, Office & People integration, to the point and content specific-only.

Now lets see the common part that still exists in to our so called “Revolutionary Devices” or Post-PC Devices:
- We are still seeing the “Menu Items” in an icon format since the inception of GUI on Desktop Computer starting from XEROX and then popularized by Apple and then the Windows inspiration from Apple.
- The Taskbar inception as we can see in T-Mobile Dash, Nokia E65 etc. This is also borrowed from Desktop PC/Mac’s task bar idea.
- Under-usage of the Desktop/Home-screen. Where as iPhone totally got-rid off from it since there debut. Android did trying to fit in the Widget placement approach. The winner in my point of view is Windows Phone 7, there desktop is somewhat talking to me according to what the People to whom I am connected is saying, calendar is more meaningful.
These are my observation so far that we are still lingering on the Icons and still borrowing it to the Post-PC Devices, not utilizing the full potential of Mobile Devices and trying our best to stuff the unneeded icons, is Windows Phone 7 trying the different approach? I think so it is, however as usual Microsoft is always a failure when it comes to a proper execution fresh ideas. I am still hoping that industry will try to adopt the idea of “Focus on Content’ rather than glossifyin the app icons representation in those Post-PC Device.
User Experience in my opinion is the content-focus approach & representing it in a way to communicate the need properly is what is missing in mobile industry (I haven’t used the HP’s WebOS and RIM upcoming Mobile OS).